David was talking quietly, steadily the way he had talked to me in 1998 in his office on Park Avenue when he had walked me through what was about to happen to me and what we were going to do about it. He had a yellow legal pad on his briefcase and he was writing on it in small careful letters as he talked and Imani was watching him write fascinated the way children are fascinated by adults who do not perform for them. Henry, he said, “Listen to me. We are going to do four things in the next 3 hours. One, we are going to your house.

You are going to walk in normally. You are going to greet your wife normally. You are going to tell her the ring was not ready, that they need another day for the resizing. She will believe you because she has spent the last 3 years believing you do not notice things. All right.

Two, while you are doing that, I am going to be in your study with Imani with my associate who is meeting us there. We are going to walk through every document in your safe. Everyone, I have a list. I know what should be there. I want to see what is actually there.

All right. Three. At some point this evening, Margaret will excuse herself to make a phone call. She will call her brother or her brother will call her. The carrier in Bermuda processes applications on a 48 hour window.

They have approximately 31 hours left before that policy goes active. They will be nervous. Nervous people use phones. And four, David looked up from his legal pad. For the first time since the jewelry store, he looked tired.

Four, he said, “You decide tonight. What you want, what I want.” Henry, there are three ways this ends. The first way, we go to the police tomorrow morning. We hand them everything.

And your wife of 42 years and her brother spend the next several years in courtrooms and possibly in prison. The second way, we go to a different set of lawyers. We structure a settlement that protects you and your son and your assets. And Margaret walks away with a number. we negotiate. Not zero, but not what she was reaching for.

The third way, he paused. He looked at Imani for a second, then back at me. The third way is that you do nothing. You confront her. You let her cry.

You let her tell you it was a misunderstanding, that her brother was acting alone, that she loves you, that 42 years means something. And you go on. You live in that house with that woman until one of you dies and you spend whatever time you have left wondering every morning what is in your coffee. He set the pen down. I am not telling you which one to choose.

He said I am telling you those are the three doors. I am telling you that you have to walk through one of them by tomorrow morning. And I am telling you, Henry, and this part one, I’m telling you as your friend, not your lawyer, that the door you choose will be the last big decision you make in this life. So, choose carefully. The car was quiet.

Imani had stopped watching the pen. She was looking at me now. Steady the way she had looked at me in the store. Mister, she said. Henry, I said, you can call me Henry.

“Mr. Henry, can I say something?” David and I both looked at her. David’s eyebrows went up a quarter of an inch. The small involuntary movement of a man who has just remembered that the 10-year-old in the car is a witness and that witnesses should not be coached and that whatever this child is about to say is going to matter. “You can say anything you want, Imani.”

She thought about it for a moment. She was choosing her words, too. Maybe 10-year-olds and lawyers are not so different when the stakes get high enough. My grandma, she said, raised me and my mom both. My mom was 16 when she had me.

My grandma worked nights cleaning offices on Wall Street. She came home at 6:00 in the morning and she made us breakfast and then she slept for 4 hours and then she went back. She did that for 9 years until she died. I didn’t say anything. Neither did David.

My grandma told me one time, Imani said that the hardest thing in the world is not knowing somebody is bad. The hardest thing in the world is knowing somebody is bad and still loving them. She said that’s the test. She said, “Most people fail it.” She looked down at her hands.

She said, “The ones who pass it are the ones who can do the hard thing anyway, not because they don’t love the person, because they do.” The car was very quiet now. Even Anthony up front had gone still in that specific way. Drivers go still when they are pretending not to listen. “I don’t know which door you should pick, Mr. Henry,” she said.

I’m 10. But my grandma said the people who pick the easy door are the people who don’t really love anybody. They just love how the person makes them feel. That’s different. She looked up.

That’s what she said. I want to be honest with you. I have negotiated with senators. I have stared down union bosses in the back of trucks in the Bronx in 1981. I have sat across from a man in Beijing in 1996 who had a folder on his desk containing every mistake I had made in the previous decade and I had not flinched.