I folded the letter and put it back in my purse, and I walked out of that room toward the chapel, because I had a eulogy to deliver and a goodbye to say, and I was not going to let him take that from me.
Chapter 3 – Claire’s Story Didn’t Add Up
The memorial service was beautiful, and I made it through my eulogy without my voice breaking, which felt like a small victory.
I talked about how Aunt Helen used to make me pick blackberries when I was a girl, and how she would tell me that the sweetest ones were always the hardest to reach.
I did not look at Richard while I spoke, and I did not look at Claire, who had slipped into the back row and was watching me with red eyes.
When the service ended, I walked to the reception hall and found a quiet corner where I could breathe.
But I had one more thing to do before I could leave.
I found Claire by the coffee table, holding a cup she was not drinking, and I asked her to walk with me.
She looked frightened, but she followed me into the corridor, and we stood where the light came through the high windows.
I told her that I wanted to hear the whole story, from the beginning, and that I would know if she was lying.
She took a deep breath and said she met Richard in March at the fund-raiser.
He was charming and attentive, and he told her he was divorced, that his ex-wife lived in another state, and that he was finally ready to start over.
She said they saw each other two or three times a week, usually for dinner or a walk in the park, and that he had never once taken her to his home.
I asked her if she had ever been to our house, and she said no.
I asked her if he had ever mentioned me, and she said only that he had said his marriage was complicated and that he was working on ending it.
I felt a cold anger settle in my chest, because that was not the man I knew, and yet it was exactly the kind of lie a man tells when he wants to have everything and give up nothing.
Claire said she started to suspect something in August, when she found a receipt in his car from a jewelry store, for a ring that was not for her.
She said she asked him about it, and he told her it was for his sister, but he did not have a sister.
That was when she decided to end it, and she wrote the letter to tell him she was done, that she did not want to be part of a lie.
She said she had also told him that she knew about the ring, and that if he did not tell his wife the truth, she would.
But she never got the chance, because he begged her to wait until after the funeral, and she agreed, and then she made the mistake of letting him kiss her one last time.
I asked her what she meant by one last time, and she said that the kiss in the visitation room was the first time they had been that close in weeks, and that she had pulled away almost immediately.
I did not know if that made it better or worse.
I asked her about the ring his mother left him, and she said he had asked her to bring it to him after the service because he wanted to give it to me as a peace offering, a way to soften the blow of a separation.
I almost laughed at that, because Richard had never been generous with his mother’s things.
I told Claire that she had been lied to, and that I did not blame her for it, but that I could not trust a word Richard said.
She nodded and said she understood, and then she did something that surprised me.
She reached into her purse and pulled out a folded piece of paper, and handed it to me.
It was another letter, in Richard’s handwriting, and it said, Claire, I need you to keep the ring until after the funeral.
My wife must never find out.
I will explain everything when we meet in the corridor.
I read it twice, and then I looked at Claire, and I saw that she was as hurt as I was, maybe more, because she had been used too.
I folded the letter and put it in my purse beside the other one, and I thanked her for telling me the truth.
She asked me what I was going to do, and I said I was going to have a conversation with my husband that he would never forget.
I walked back into the reception hall and saw Richard standing by the window, his phone in his hand, his face tense.
He looked up when he saw me, and I could see that he was about to say something.
But I did not give him the chance.






