Chapter 4

“I said, ‘I’m going to show you my identification’ before I moved,” Monroe said, not raising his voice, not needing to. “Ask her.” He nodded toward Ruth. “Ask him.” He nodded toward Hollis Grant, the retiree, who was sitting very still with his tow receipt folded into quarters in his lap.Hollis didn’t answer right away. That hesitation was its own kind of information: not a lie, not yet a truth, just a man deciding whether this was his fight to be in.Kittredge didn’t ask him. He picked up the radio again instead: “Dispatch, update. Subject remains uncooperative. Requesting a supervisor be advised the lobby cameras are down for maintenance.”He glanced at Ruth as he said it, like he was daring her to correct him over the air. She didn’t. She wrote the time on her sticky notepad instead, next to the earlier one, and slid it under the counter where he couldn’t see it. That was the second record Kittredge didn’t know existed yet.Monroe’s phone buzzed against the floor beside him. Doyle had knocked it loose along with the folio, and Kittredge picked it up before Monroe could. ASAC Vance, the screen read.Kittredge held it a second too long—the way a man holds something he doesn’t understand and doesn’t want to ask about—then set it down within Monroe’s reach, screen still lit.Monroe answered on speaker, because his hands weren’t steady enough yet to hold it to his ear without everyone noticing.”Isaiah,” a woman’s voice came through, controlled, already moving fast. “I have a missed-check alert on your appointment. Talk to me.””I was assaulted by an officer at the front desk,” Monroe said. “I’m not hurt badly. The building’s on some kind of hold. Miss Ellison says it’s tied to the appointment flag, not to anything I did.”A pause followed. Doyle watched Kittredge’s face while Vance spoke.”You are not running point on this,” Vance said. “You’re a witness and you’re a victim, not an investigator. Not today. Stay where people can see you. Don’t sign anything. I’m sending someone.””Understood.”Vance hung up. Kittredge hadn’t moved. Neither had Ruth, who was watching Monroe now with an expression that had shifted somewhere in the last ninety seconds from professional concern into something closer to recognition.”I have a 1:30 with the records custodian,” Monroe said again—to the room this time, not to Doyle. “I never got that far.”Ruth set down her pen. “That’s me,” she said. “I’m the custodian. I’ve had your request folder ready since Tuesday.”Kittredge’s expression didn’t move, but his pen, still in his hand, still poised over nothing, stopped completely.

Chapter 5

“Ray,” Ruth said to him, using his first name for what sounded like the first time all shift, “why does that bother you?”He didn’t answer. He looked instead toward the corridor that ran past the front desk, past the interview rooms, to the property room at the back of the building—the same corridor his own badge would need to open in about six minutes. His hand had started to shake very slightly around a pen that wasn’t writing anything.”Let’s get you somewhere quieter,” Kittredge said, already moving toward the back hallway. “Away from all this. We can get you looked at properly.””I’m fine where people can see me,” Monroe said. “Agent Vance told me to stay in view of the cameras.””The cameras are down.””Then I’ll stay in view of the room.”Because Monroe didn’t move, Kittredge didn’t push it. Not with Priya Anand already kneeling beside him, two fingers light against his cheekbone, her voice dropping into the flat, careful register of someone documenting rather than comforting.”Swelling here. Laceration about a centimeter, consistent with a closed-fist strike,” she said, mostly to herself, then louder to the room: “Somebody should be writing this down.””I’m writing it down,” Ruth said, and did.Doyle leaned in before Priya could finish. “You’ll want to say he came at me first. That’s closer to what actually happened.”Priya didn’t look up from Monroe’s cheek. “I’ll say what I saw, not what’s closer to anything.””Then say it slower,” Doyle said, “so it comes out right.”She finished her count of the laceration and stood. And for the first time since the punch, she looked directly at Doyle instead of past him. “I’ve written a hundred of these. Yours won’t be the one I get wrong.”That should have ended it. It didn’t.Kittredge turned back to Ruth instead, changing targets the way a man does when the first argument isn’t working. “This flag on his appointment… when did it go up?””Tuesday,” Ruth said.”Tuesday?” Kittredge repeated it like the word might come out different the second time. “And you didn’t think that was worth mentioning to me?””Why would I mention a records hold to a sergeant?” Ruth said. “It’s not unusual. We get them for subpoenaed material.” She paused, and something in her face changed—the pause of someone connecting two facts she hadn’t put next to each other until just now. “Actually, it is unusual. We’ve had exactly one other flagged appointment this year. Same category, same source.””What source?” Monroe asked.