More importantly, the investigation concluded that Castellano’s nine previous complaints should have been taken more seriously. A pattern review showed that all nine complaints described similar behavior: Castellano assuming people of color didn’t belong in certain neighborhoods, Castellano demanding ID without legal justification, Castellano being aggressive in situations that didn’t warrant aggression.

The investigation also revealed that Lieutenant Kowalski had been deliberately vague in his investigations of Castellano’s complaints. Kowalski’s reports used phrases like “officer was conducting legitimate police work” and “complainant misunderstood standard procedures” without actually examining whether the stops met constitutional standards.

In three cases, Kowalski hadn’t even interviewed Castellano before closing the complaint as unfounded; he had simply reviewed Castellano’s incident report and accepted it at face value. In two other cases, Kowalski had interviewed Castellano but hadn’t asked any challenging questions about why the stop was made or whether racial bias might have been a factor.

The previous supervisor had failed to identify the pattern—or worse, had identified it and chose to ignore it. The investigators noted in their report that Kowalski’s failure to properly supervise Castellano had allowed a problematic officer to continue violating citizens’ rights for years.

The recommendation was termination.

Castellano’s union fought it, arguing that he had been responding to a legitimate call and that his actions, while perhaps overly aggressive, didn’t rise to the level of termination.

The department’s response was simple: Castellano had profiled a sergeant based on race. If he would do that to a superior officer, what was he doing to regular citizens who didn’t have the knowledge or resources to fight back?

The union’s argument failed. Castellano was terminated nine weeks after the incident. His appeal was denied. His law enforcement career was over at age 28.

But the consequences went beyond just Castellano. The department launched a comprehensive review of how civilian complaints were handled. They found that under the previous supervisor, Lieutenant Kowalski, complaint investigations had been cursory at best.

The review examined 127 complaints that Kowalski had investigated over his final five years as a supervisor. Of those, 94 alleged some form of discrimination or excessive force; Kowalski had found merit in only three. The rest were dismissed as unfounded, unsubstantiated, or complainant withdrew.

But when Internal Affairs reexamined 30 of those complaints with access to body camera footage and dispatch records that Kowalski hadn’t reviewed, they found patterns of problematic behavior in 18 cases: officers making stops without reasonable suspicion, officers using force in situations that didn’t warrant it, officers making racially coded comments.

Kowalski’s failure to investigate properly hadn’t just protected Castellano; it had protected multiple officers whose conduct needed to be addressed. The department published a scathing report criticizing Kowalski’s supervision and noting that his failure to properly investigate complaints had allowed problematic behavior to continue unchecked throughout his division.

Kowalski had retired six months before the Whitmore incident, so he couldn’t be disciplined. But the department stripped him of his retirement ceremony honors and made it clear that his legacy would be one of failed leadership. Several community leaders called for Kowalski to return his pension, though legally that wasn’t possible.

The department also implemented sweeping new protocols based on what the investigation had revealed:

All complaints alleging racial profiling would be investigated by Internal Affairs, not by division supervisors, eliminating the conflict of interest that had allowed Kowalski to protect his officers.

All stops would be reviewed quarterly for patterns of racial disparity. The department hired a data analyst whose sole job was to track stop data, looking for officers whose stops showed racial disparities that couldn’t be explained by legitimate factors.

All body camera footage from investigatory stops would be randomly audited to ensure officers were following proper procedures: 5% of all stops each month would be pulled at random and reviewed by a team of supervisors and community representatives.

The department created a civilian review board with actual power. Previous civilian oversight had been advisory only; the new board could compel testimony, access all records, and make binding recommendations on discipline for sustained complaints.

Officers were required to complete 16 hours of implicit bias training annually, not the previous two-hour online module that officers could click through without paying attention. The new training was in-person, interactive, and included scenarios designed to make officers confront their own biases.

The department also established an early warning system that would flag officers who showed patterns of problematic behavior before it rose to the level of sustained complaints. If an officer had three complaints alleging similar conduct within a year, even if none were sustained, they would be automatically flagged for additional supervision and training.

Whitmore was involved in developing the new training program on implicit bias and racial profiling. He shared his own experience with the body camera footage as a training example. Officers watched a respected sergeant get profiled by one of their own; it was powerful and uncomfortable, which was exactly the point.

The training didn’t just show Whitmore’s incident. It showed the body camera footage from several of Castellano’s previous stops. Officers watched Castellano stop the attorney while jogging. They watched him harass the business owner outside her own store. They watched him make a college student empty his backpack. Then, trainers asked the officers to identify what reasonable suspicion Castellano had in each case. The answer was always the same: none. The only common factor was the race of the person being stopped.

Whitmore also became an advocate for officers of color within the department. He discovered that he wasn’t the only Black officer who had experienced discrimination. Several others shared stories of being stopped by fellow officers while off-duty, being questioned about why they were in certain neighborhoods, being assumed to be suspects rather than officers.