Hargrove’s body camera recorded his hand moving to his handcuffs, captured the audio of the metal jingling as he pulled them from his belt. “You’re refusing a lawful order from a police officer. That’s obstruction. Put your hands behind your back.”
The camera captured Terrance holding up his phone, his voice steady. “I’m recording this interaction. You are on my private property without a warrant. I have not committed any crime. You have no legal authority to be here, to demand my ID, or to search any part of my property. State your probable cause or leave.”
What happened next was captured in perfect clarity on Hargrove’s body camera. The footage shows his hand reaching out, grabbing for Terrance’s phone; shows Terrance pulling it back; shows Hargrove’s hands grabbing his arm instead, twisting it behind his back in a motion rough enough that the camera’s image shook slightly. The audio picked up Terrance’s sharp intake of breath as Hargrove forced handcuffs onto his wrists.
The camera angle, mounted on Hargrove’s chest, looked down at Terrance’s hands as Hargrove deliberately overtightened the cuffs until they bit into his skin. “You’re under arrest for obstruction of justice and resisting arrest.”
The body camera captured Terrance’s calm response despite the pain. “Officer Hargrove, I can see your nameplate. I’m a constitutional law professor. You’re committing multiple federal crimes right now. I’m being cooperative. I haven’t resisted. You’re arresting me on my own property for asserting my Fourth Amendment rights.”
A voice called out from the neighboring yard, and Hargrove’s camera caught him turning toward the sound. “Hey, what’s going on over there?”
Terrance’s neighbor, Diane Kessler, was standing at the fence line with her phone out, recording. Hargrove’s body camera captured Diane’s face—shocked, outraged—as she took in the scene.
“Diane, call my attorney. Officer Hargrove just walked onto my property without a warrant and arrested me for building a fence.”
Hargrove’s camera recorded him looking at Diane, the annoyance clear in his voice. “Ma’am, this doesn’t concern you. Step back from the fence.”
Diane’s voice came through strong on the body camera audio. “I’m recording this interaction. That’s Dr. Terrance Holloway, a tenured law professor. He owns that house. What probable cause do you have for being on his property?”
Hargrove ignored her, and his body camera recorded the walk to his patrol car, the angle bouncing slightly with each step. The camera captured Terrance’s face in profile as Hargrove guided him toward the side gate, his expression controlled, but his jaw tight with suppressed anger.
Diane called 911 while still recording with her phone. “911, what’s your emergency?”
“This is Diane Kessler at 815 Westgate Avenue. A police officer just trespassed onto my neighbor’s property and arrested him without cause. The neighbor is Dr. Terrance Holloway, a law professor. He was building a fence in his own yard. The officer had no warrant and no probable cause. I need a supervisor here immediately.”
Hargrove heard this through the fence, and his body camera recorded his frustrated expression as he stopped walking. The camera captured his annoyed response: “Ma’am, if you continue to interfere with this arrest, I’ll arrest you, too.”
Diane’s voice came through clear on the body camera audio: “You can’t arrest someone for calling 911! I’m on my own property. I’m exercising my First Amendment right to record police activity, and I’m reporting what appears to be an illegal arrest.”
Hargrove continued walking Terrance to his patrol car, his body camera bouncing with each step. The footage captured him opening the back door, guiding Terrance inside. The camera angle showed Terrance’s wrists already bruising from the too-tight handcuffs.
He put Terrance in the back of his patrol car, and his body camera recorded him walking back through the side gate into the backyard. Diane’s voice called out from the fence, and the camera captured her still recording with her phone.
Hargrove’s body camera shows him approaching the garden shed. The footage captures his hand reaching out, opening the door. The camera recorded the interior: garden tools on hooks, bags of soil, fertilizer, plant pots, a wheelbarrow.
“Officer, you cannot search that shed! You don’t have a warrant or consent!”
The body camera recorded Hargrove ignoring Diane completely. The footage shows his hands appearing in frame, pulling out tools, moving bags, searching through everything. The audio captured his breathing as he searched for something, anything that would justify his illegal entry. He found nothing, because there was nothing illegal to find. But his body camera recorded every second of the illegal search: every drawer opened, every bag moved, every tool examined.
Diane’s phone was recording from the fence line, but Hargrove’s body camera provided something even more damning: his first-person perspective, his choices, his complete lack of legal justification, captured from his own chest-mounted camera.
A supervisor arrived 12 minutes later. Lieutenant Andre Baptiste pulled up, saw Terrance handcuffed in the patrol car, and approached Hargrove, who was still going through the shed.
“Hargrove, what’s the situation?”
Hargrove straightened up, holding a bag of fertilizer like it was evidence. His body camera recorded the entire exchange. “Lieutenant, subject was building without a permit. When I attempted to verify, he became hostile and refused to provide ID. I arrested him for obstruction. I’m conducting a search based on probable cause.”
Baptiste looked at the small fence posts, at Terrance’s tools laid out neatly, at the bag of fertilizer that was clearly marked as organic garden supply. “What probable cause?”
“Subject’s behavior was suspicious. Building structures without permits often indicates other code violations or illegal activity.”
Baptiste walked over to the patrol car and looked at Terrance through the window. He saw a man in jeans and a university T-shirt, covered in dirt from working in his yard, with no visible signs of aggression or resistance. He opened the door. “Sir, I’m Lieutenant Baptiste. Can you tell me what happened?”






