For four years, I had operated under the quiet arrogance of believing I knew her. I knew she hated the sound of thunderstorms and slept with a fan on even in January. I knew she always squeezed two lemon wedges into her iced tea, that she cried every time she watched the end of About Time, and that she hadn’t spoken to her father since her mother’s divorce ten years ago. I thought I had mapped every corner of her.
Standing in that doorway, I realized there were entire wings of her mind I had never even been given a key to.
“Olivia,” I said softly.
Her shoulders slumped. When she finally spoke, the words were barely audible. “I’ve been having doubts.”
They were four ordinary words. They also managed to dismantle four years of my life in less than two seconds.
“How long?” I asked.
“Since the summer.”
Since the summer. While I was working sixty-hour weeks to cover the down payment, while I was sitting at the dining table addressing cream-colored envelopes in my terrible handwriting, she had been lying beside me in the dark, wondering how to get out.
“Why didn’t you say anything?”
“Because I didn’t want to hurt you.”
I let out a slow breath, watching it vanish in the cool air of the unheated room. “That wasn’t your call to make.”
Tears spilled over her lashes, cutting bright tracks down her cheeks. “I know.”
Jason stepped forward, breaking the line between us. “Ethan, there’s something else you need to know.”
“By all means,” I said. “Let’s clear the deck.”
He glanced at Olivia, a look of genuine exhaustion passing over his features. “Last Friday, when I told you I had feelings for her, I also told you I was leaving town.”
Olivia’s head snapped up. “What?”
“I got an offer in Seattle,” Jason said quietly. “Senior logistics director. I applied back in August.”
I frowned, the pieces refusing to sit flat. “You never mentioned Seattle to me.”
“Because I hadn’t decided if I was going to take it.”
Olivia stared at him, her eyes wide and glistening. “You told me you weren’t going anywhere.”
“I told you that before the offer came through on Thursday.”
“And you told him?”
“I told him because he asked me why I was acting like a ghost,” Jason said.
I remembered Murphy’s now—the sticky mahogany table, the neon glow of the beer signs reflecting off the rain-streaked window. Jason had barely touched his whiskey. When I’d asked him what was eating at him, he’d stared at his glass for a full minute before saying, Sometimes the person you care about most is the person you have to walk away from.
At the time, I’d assumed he was still untangling himself from his ex-girlfriend, Sarah. I had clapped him on the shoulder and ordered him another round.
I looked at Olivia. “Did you know about Seattle?”
She hesitated, then gave a tiny, reluctant nod. “Yes.”
“Since when?”
“Two weeks ago.”
“Two weeks,” I repeated. “So you two have been having a quiet little summit about your future while I’ve been finalizing the caterer.”
“No,” Olivia said quickly.
Jason cut in before she could build another half-truth. “She texted me this morning and asked me to come over. She wanted to talk before the rehearsal dinner next week.”
“Then why were you sitting on my bed?”
Neither of them moved. The rain drummed harder against the glass.
Finally, Olivia’s voice broke. “Because I asked him not to go.”
The words hung in the air between us, stripped of any grace. There was no spin left to put on it. It was just the bare, ugly bone of the truth.
I looked at the woman I had intended to marry, and a strange, hollow calm settled over me. “Did you sleep together?”
Olivia brought both hands up to cover her face.
Jason looked at the floor.
Silence, it turned out, was the loudest answer either of them could have given.
I nodded slowly, once, as if confirming an appointment. “Thank you for finally being honest.”
“Ethan, please,” Olivia gasped, lowering her hands. Her eyes were red-rimmed and frantic. “I know how this looks. I know I’ve ruined everything, but I still love you. I do.”
I studied her for a long moment. I looked for the woman who had stayed up with me in the hospital the night my father died, holding my hand until my fingers went numb. I couldn’t find her. “I don’t think you know what that word means anymore.”
She took a step toward me, her hand half-raised.
I stepped back into the hallway. “I need you both to leave.”
Jason didn’t argue. He bent down, scooped his canvas jacket off the floor, and draped it over his arm.
Olivia didn’t budge. “This is our house,” she whispered.
I looked past her—at the stacked boxes of wedding favors in the corner, at the paint swatches, at the unmade bed. We hadn’t even moved the furniture in, and the foundation was already cracked down the middle.
“It’s my name on the temporary deed,” I said quietly. “You can send someone for your things next week. We don’t have to settle the rest of it today.”
She stared at me, the color draining from her lips. “You’re calling off the wedding?”
My eyes dropped to the slim platinum band on her left hand—the one I had spent three months paying off before I’d even asked her. “I can’t marry a stranger, Olivia.”
For the first time since I’d walked through the door, she didn’t have an argument left.
Jason moved past me into the hallway. At the top of the stairs, he paused, his hand resting on the banister. “Ethan.”
I didn’t turn around.
“I owe you an apology,” he said.
“You owe me a lot more than that.”
“I never wanted to blow up ten years of friendship.”






