Chapter 8 – The Two Options I Gave Him at His Own Table
I hired a lawyer on a Friday.
Marlene set it up through her firm and the lawyer’s name was Ms. Coley and she had gray hair cut short and glasses on a chain and she had been doing family law for twenty-eight years and she did not once ask me if I was sure.
I brought her the flash drive, the bank statements, the cashier’s check records, the business search, and a note with Paul’s phone number on it.
She read for about forty minutes without saying anything.
Then she looked up and said, “Mrs. Harper, on the signature page of this home equity line, is that your signature?”
“That is what I thought,” she said.
“The stroke on the H is wrong and there’s no pen pressure variation.
This is what we call a traced signature.
On a loan against a home, with a notary stamp on it, that is a felony in this state.”
I sat in a leather chair in an office that smelled like coffee and old carpet and I felt the room tilt.
“Do you want to file a police report or do you want to negotiate?”
“I want to file the report first and negotiate second.
I want the report on record before he knows the report exists.”
She actually smiled at that.
I filed the report the following Monday.
Alvarez, because the stamp was on the paperwork and because the date on the appointment — a Sunday — was the same weekend I had been told Daniel was on a bidding trip in Ohio.
The officer who took the report was a woman about my age and she asked me to sign two forms and she said somebody from the fraud unit would be in touch.
She did not look impressed with my story.
Two days later the notary’s name was confirmed in the state database, and Ms. Coley called me and said the notary’s stamp book had been photographed at Vanessa’s apartment by Vanessa herself, months ago, because Vanessa had gotten suspicious of Daniel too, and Vanessa’s roommate happened to be the notary’s cousin, and that is how a signing got done on a Sunday at a UPS store on Route 9 with a woman who had never met me signing my name.
I did not know what to feel about Vanessa by then.
I still do not, some days.
She was lied to and she lied.
She is carrying a baby that will have a father who is about to be charged, and she handed me the file that was going to take him down, and I have never decided which one of those things is the real one.
I asked Daniel to meet me at the house on a Wednesday at eleven in the morning, which is a time I knew he could make because it was a time he had used before, when I was supposed to be at the office.
He walked in like a man who thought he was coming to negotiate with his wife.
He sat down at the kitchen table.
The same table where I set four places for years.
The same table where Emily learned to write her name with a purple marker.
I did not raise my voice once.
I put a folder on the table and I opened it and I turned it around to face him.
“These are the draws on the home equity line,” I said.
This is the business search with Paul’s name on it.
This is the police report I filed on Monday.
This is the notary’s name and the notary’s date and the notary’s stamp.”
Daniel looked at the papers.
“Are you kidding me?” he said.
“Nobody is going to believe a hysterical housewife about a notary.
You went and threw a fit in the bedroom with a broom in your hand.
That is the story that is going to be told.”
He was already standing up.
And that was when I reached over and opened my phone and set it on the table between us and played the recording.
Paul’s voice filled my kitchen.
“Sara, he has a second key.
He keeps it in his truck.
He would call me sometimes at lunch and say he was going by the house because he knew you were at the office until four.”
The color went out of his face, ear to ear, like water draining out of a sink.
“You have two options,” I said.
You sign the separation agreement Ms. Coley is sending you this afternoon.
You keep Emily’s routine exactly the way it is and you put it in writing that you opened that loan in my name.
This folder and this recording and the notary’s name go to the county, and I let the state figure out the rest of it.”
He did not say anything for close to a minute.
Then he did the thing he always did, my husband of twelve years.
He asked me to think about Emily.
And I told him the truth, which was that I had been thinking about Emily since the moment she stepped into our bedroom doorway behind me, and that everything I had done in the two weeks since then had been for her, and that if he wanted to bring her name into the room he was welcome to, because she was the only person in this family who had never once lied to either of us.