I folded the sheet and put it in my pocket again and I did not let it out of my sight for the rest of that night.

Chapter 2 – The Woman in the Red Dress Called Me

Two days later, my phone rang with a number I did not recognize.

I almost let it go to voicemail.

I answered on the fourth ring.

“Is this Claire?”

A woman’s voice, young, careful, like she had rehearsed the first sentence at least ten times.

“Who is this?”

“My name is Nicole.

I was at your house on Tuesday.”

I stood up from the kitchen table and walked out onto the back porch.

“I have nothing to say to you.”

“I know.

I just—” She stopped.

“I didn’t know he was married.”

I did not answer.

“I’m serious.

I found out that night, same as you.

He told me he was divorced.

He told me he lived alone in a house on the east side.

I never even knew he lived on your street until I pulled into your driveway and saw a woman’s car in the garage.”

“Then why did you come inside?”

Silence.

“Because he said the house was his.

Because I had never seen a ring on his hand.

Because I’m an idiot, I guess.”

I sat down on the step.

“What do you want from me, Nicole?”

“I want to know if I’m the only one.”

That was the first sentence in two days that made me feel something other than cold.

We met the next morning at a diner off the highway, halfway between my house and hers.

She was smaller in daylight, no red dress, just a gray sweater and her hair pulled back, and she looked tired in a way that made me believe her.

We ordered coffee and did not drink it.

“How long?”

I asked.

“About a year.”

“A year.”

“He told me he was divorced.

I saw his place a couple of times, or what I thought was his place.

I never spent the night.”

“He has a house,” I said.

“I’ve been living in it for twelve years.”

She looked down at the table.

“I know.

I feel sick about it.”

“What did he tell you he did for a living?”

“Flooring.

Same thing he told me he had always done.”

“Did you ever see pictures?”

She looked up.

“What do you mean?”

“Of his house.

You said he showed you a house.

What did it look like?”

Nicole thought for a second.

“I saw it on his phone.

It was nice.

Two-story, brick, a big front porch.

He said he had just bought it.”

“And?”

“And I asked him later if I could see the inside and he kept putting me off.

Then one day he showed me a room from inside it, on his phone, and I remember thinking it was weird.”

“What was weird?”

“There were no pictures.”

“No pictures of what?”

“No pictures of anything.

No family photos, no art, no dishes on the counters.

Nothing on the walls.

It looked like a staged house, like something a realtor would show you.”

I sat with that for a minute.

“Nicole, the listing sheet he had at my house, it was for my address.

My house.”

She set her cup down hard.

“Wait.

What?”

“I found it on the coffee table that night.

Our address, our floor plan, a price, everything.

Filed with his company nine days before I walked in on you.”

She looked at me for a long moment.

“He asked me for money.”

“What?”

“Two months ago.

Not a lot, four thousand, but he said he had a cash-flow problem with a job and he would pay me back in two weeks.

Then he paid me back in four days, full amount, like it was nothing.”

I felt my hands go cold around my coffee cup.

“Last month, Daniel brought home paperwork for a refinance on our house,” I said.

“He said it was for the business.

I signed it without reading it because he has always handled that side of things.

I’ve been doing payroll for him part-time for six years, Nicole.

I have signed a hundred documents he handed me.”

Nicole reached for her purse and pulled out her phone.

“There’s something I need to show you.”

She scrolled for a while with her thumb.

“I saw this one time when he left his laptop open at my apartment.

I took a picture of the screen because it looked strange and I did not know what it was.”

She turned the phone around and set it flat on the table between us.

It was a photograph of a bank app on a laptop screen.

An open joint account.

On the account name, two sets of initials.

C.B. and then a hyphen, and then the name Nicole.

“I looked it up after Tuesday,” she said.

“It’s a real account.

It’s still open.

I don’t know how, because I never signed anything.”

I stared at the initials on her screen and I could not breathe right for a second.

C.B. was me.

Claire Bennett.

And on the same account, in a row I had never seen, my name was sitting right next to hers.

“What bank is that?”

I heard myself ask.

“Mercy Trust.

Downtown branch.”

I picked up my coffee, but I did not drink it.

“Nicole,” I said.

“The night you were at my house, he did not ask me to forgive him.

He asked me for that listing sheet.”

She did not say anything.

“He did not ask about you.

He did not ask about me.

He asked for the paper.”

Nicole nodded slowly, like she had been thinking the same thing for two days and had finally met someone who agreed with her.

“Then we should probably go find out how many other papers there are,” she said.