And I sat there in my sister’s kitchen and understood that the man who kissed a woman in a red dress on our sofa had been practicing my name.
Chapter 5 – He Kept a Key to a Door I Was Never Allowed to Open
Nicole called me on a Thursday morning, three days after I changed the locks.
She didn’t say hello first.
“I met him about a year ago,” she said.
“At a bar downtown.
He told me he was divorced.
He told me the divorce was final.”
I was standing in Margaret’s kitchen with a dish towel in my hand, and I set it down on the counter and just listened.
“I believed him,” Nicole said.
“I know how that sounds.”
“It doesn’t sound like anything,” I said.
“I was married to him for twelve years and I didn’t know either.”
She was quiet for a second, and then she said the thing that made me sit down at the table.
“He had a key,” she said.
“A key to a storage unit on Route 9, past the lumber yard.
He kept papers in there.
He never let me go inside.
One time I asked him what was in it and he said it was work files and I let it go.”
I asked her how she knew the address.
She said she’d followed him there once because he was acting strange, back in the winter, and she sat in her car at the end of the lot and watched him go in and come out.
She never told him she did that.
I sat with that for a minute.
Then I said, “Do you still have the key?”
She said no, he took it back.
But she said she knew the unit number.
We met at the lot the next afternoon, and I’ll be honest with you, I drove there fully prepared to be wrong.
I told myself on the whole drive that this woman might be lying to me, that she might be some part of this thing I couldn’t see, and that I was being an idiot for going anywhere with her.
That’s the thing nobody tells you about being cheated on.
After a while you don’t trust your own read on people anymore.
She was already there when I pulled in, standing by her car in a plain coat, no red dress, and she looked about ten years younger than me and about a hundred years more tired than a person that age should look.
“Unit 214,” she said.
The lock was a cheap padlock, the kind you buy at a hardware store for eight dollars.
She had a bolt cutter in her trunk.
I want you to understand that I stood there and thought about it.
I thought about calling Margaret.
I thought about turning around and going home and letting a lawyer do all of this.
Then I thought about the folder under Daniel’s desk with my name signed on it three times in handwriting that wasn’t mine.
I told her to cut it.
The inside of that unit smelled like dust and old cardboard.
There were six plastic bins stacked against the back wall and a metal shelf on the side, and on the shelf there were dozens of manila folders, all of them labeled in his blocky handwriting.
Not numbers.
Names.
Female names.
Nicole stood behind me and didn’t say a word, and I heard her breathe in through her nose once, hard, like she’d been hit in the stomach.
Chapter 6 – Rebecca Answered on the Second Ring
Her phone number was still active.
I found it in one of the printed emails inside the Rebecca folder, written at the bottom of the page next to a line that said call me back before Friday.
I sat in my car in the storage lot for fifteen minutes before I dialed it.
She picked up on the second ring.
“Hello?”
I said my name and said I was calling about Daniel Marsh, and there was a long pause on the other end, and then she said, “Which one?”
I didn’t know what to say to that.
“You’re not the first woman who’s called me,” she said.
“But you’re the first one in three years.”
Her name was Rebecca Cole, and she lived two hours east, just over the state line, in a small town with one stoplight and a post office.
She told me to come in the afternoon, when her kids would still be at school, and she gave me an address.
I asked Nicole if she wanted to come with me.
She said she thought it would be better if I went alone, and she was right.
I drove out there on a Saturday, and I met her in front of her house, a little ranch with a chain-link fence and a maple tree in the yard, and she was in her early forties with gray coming in at her temples and a wedding ring on a chain around her neck that wasn’t from Daniel.
She invited me in and made coffee and we sat at her kitchen table, and I put the folder and the emails on the table between us.
She looked at the top page for a long time without touching it.
“I was an office assistant at his business for two years,” she said.
“Six years ago.
The year he was supposed to be getting divorced.”
I asked her if he ever gave her a ring.
She laughed once, no humor in it.
“He never married me,” she said.
“He told me his first marriage was a mistake and he was done with that part of his life.
I stayed long enough to believe him.
Then one Tuesday he didn’t come home, and I found out from a guy on his crew that he was already with someone else.”
I asked her about the money.
She got up and went into the other room and came back with a bank statement and a court paper stapled to it.
“He borrowed eleven thousand dollars from me in installments,” she said.
“Every time it was temporary.
Every time it was going to come back to me next month.
I had to take him to court to try to get it, and I got a judgment, and I never collected a dollar.”
She tapped the court paper with her finger.
“He still owes court fines from that case.
Small town, small court, but it’s on the record.
I never got any of it back.”
I asked her if she ever heard from him again.
She said no, and then she said something that made the whole summer reorganize itself in my head.
“He did the same thing to a woman in Ohio before me,” she said.
“I found out after, from her sister.
Same story.
Different house, different town, different name on the paperwork.
He doesn’t leave, he just moves.”
I sat there in her kitchen and thought about twelve years.
Twelve years, and I had never once considered that Daniel had a pattern, because the way he told it, every problem in his life had been caused by somebody else.
Rebecca got up and went to the back of the house and came back holding something small in her hand.
It was a notebook.
Pocket-sized, black cover, bent at the corner.
“He left this behind,” she said.
“It was in a jacket he left at my place.
I always meant to throw it away.”
She set it on the table and slid it toward me.
I opened it.
The whole notebook was rows of dates on the left side and dollar amounts on the right side, fifty or sixty pages of them, in his handwriting, the same blocky letters as the folder labels in the storage unit.
Some of the amounts had little marks next to them, checks or X’s, like he was keeping score of something.
I flipped toward the back, past the middle, and stopped.
The last written page had a single date on it.
And next to that date, in the same handwriting, was my name.
Claire.
It was a date about four months from now.
I looked up at Rebecca and she was watching my face, and she didn’t look surprised at all.
“That’s why I kept it,” she said.
“I didn’t know who you were.






