Share this article:
Chapter 5 – Fourteen Months of Other People’s Lives
Chapter 5 – Fourteen Months of Other People’s Lives
I did not sleep in our bed that night.
I took the guest room and shut the door and put my phone face up on the nightstand, and I woke at four with my heart going like I had been running.
By six I was in my office with the corridor lights off and the door closed.
I want to tell you what I did first, because it matters to everything after.
I did not call a divorce lawyer.
I opened my own closed files.
I started with the ledger and worked backward one row at a time, and the first name on it was Reeves.
The Reeves matter was a wrongful death case I tried two years ago for a woman named Delia Reeves, whose son was killed by a delivery truck that ran a light on Fulton Avenue.
The defense offered thirty thousand dollars before the deposition, and I told Delia to refuse it, because I had the driver on his phone and I had the maintenance records and I believed we were going to win something real.
We settled for ninety thousand, and I could never explain to myself why it came apart the way it did.
Sitting there with that card in my hand, I finally could.
The Reeves row was paid out over five weeks in small amounts, and beside one of those payments someone had typed the words expert notes, and the date on that row was eight days before the driver’s deposition.
I sat back in my chair and thought about the fact that the driver had walked into that room already knowing what my reconstruction expert was going to say.
Atwater was the same.
The Atwater settlement collapsed in discovery because opposing counsel produced a document they should never have had, and I blamed my own filing, and I apologized to that client twice.
I do not think I am telling you anything strange.
Most lawyers I know carry two or three cases like that around for the rest of their lives, the ones they cannot quite account for.
I called Delia Reeves at nine fifteen that morning.
She answered on the third ring, and I said, “Mrs. Reeves, this is Neravine Ashworth,” and the silence on the line lasted long enough that I could hear her breathing.
“I know who you are,” she said.
I told her I was calling about her case, and that I needed to ask her something difficult.
I asked whether anyone on the defense side had ever mentioned her son’s medical records.
She said, “They knew about the therapist.
They brought it up at the deposition like they had been sitting in the room with him.”
I asked if she had ever given those records to anyone.
She said no, and then she said, “Why are you asking me this now?”
I did not have a clean answer for her.
I told her I was reviewing old matters, which was the truest thing I could say without saying the rest, and then I told her I was sorry.
“Sorry for what?” she said.
I said I did not know yet, and I meant it, and I wrote the time and the date of that call on a legal pad and put the page in a folder.
That is the part I want you to hear clearly.
I was finished being the person this happened to.
I sat in my car in the garage with the engine off and decided what I was going to do, and it took less than a minute.
I was going to build a file.
Not a case file.
My file.
The room logs went in first, then a copy of the card, then Quade’s statement with his initials on the bottom of it, then the message thread with Slate and the words the partner wants the Kessler log.
Then I walked down to human resources and asked for a personnel file, and the woman at that desk did not question me, because I am a partner and partners ask for things.
I read Brielletta’s application in the copy room with the door shut.
Her resume was thin, five years of records work and two employers nobody answered for when I called.
The reference letter in the back of the file was signed by Douglas Halbrook.
It called her the most capable records professional he had ever had the pleasure to work with, and it was dated the eleventh of March.
I turned the page and read the posting notice clipped underneath it.
The records specialist position had opened on the twelfth of June.
The letter was three months older than the job.
Share this article:
Chapter 6 – The Name on the Ledger Was My Mentor’s
Chapter 6 – The Name on the Ledger Was My Mentor’s
I did not sleep that night, so I did what I always do when I cannot sleep.
I read.
The name on the last row of the spreadsheet was not a person at all.
It was a trust, the Halbrook Family Trust, registered in Franklin County in 2011, with Douglas Halbrook as trustee and his wife named as successor.
I sat there with the phone in my hand and felt something in my chest go quiet and cold.
Douglas Halbrook hired me in 2004, when I was twenty-seven and had nothing but a license and a borrowed suit.
He taught me how to read a contract, how to sit still in a deposition, how to lose without letting it show on my face.
I trusted him more than I trusted my husband, which now strikes me as a very low bar.
At seven I opened the court’s electronic docket and searched my own name.
Three of my cases had settled this year without a word to me.
In each one, a notice of appearance for Douglas Halbrook had been filed eleven days before the settlement, adding him as counsel of record on a matter I had been trying for eighteen months.
In each one, the settlement came in under a quarter of what the file was worth.
I read the three dismissal notices twice, and then I printed them, because paper does not lie and paper does not delete itself.
The reference letter dated March eleventh was still in my bag.
I carried it down the hall with the printouts and the county filing, and I knocked on his door at ten past nine.
He waved me in and kept talking on the phone for another minute, and I stood there and let him.
When he hung up he said, “You look like a woman who has been up all night.”
“I have,” I said.
I laid the county filing on his desk first.
Then the three






