Share this article:

Chapter 9 – The Last Exhibit I Signed

Chapter 9 – The Last Exhibit I Signed

I testified on a Tuesday morning in a hearing room with no windows, and I kept my hands flat on the table so no one could see them shake.

My attorney, Renata Cho, sat to my left and did not touch my arm or comfort me once, which was the kindest thing she did all year.

The investigator from the disciplinary office asked the questions, and the first one was simple.

“In your own words, Ms. Kessler-Ashworth, when did you first know that exhibits from Kessler v.

Vantor Medical had left this building?”

I said the date, the time, and the name of the room, and then I said the rest of it for four hours.

I described the filing cabinets and the padded envelope and the memory card I had slammed on that table.

I described the spreadsheet with forty-one rows on it and my own initials typed in twice.

I described a reference letter dated the eleventh of March for a job that opened in June.

Quade testified the following week.

He had been charged by then, and his lawyer had worked out an arrangement, and he read from a statement in a flat voice that I had never heard him use before.

He said Corbin Slate paid him, and that Douglas Halbrook approved the arrangement and took his cut through the trust account ending in 4471.

He said the affair with Brielletta started in the spring, and that the thefts started fourteen months before that, and that the two things were never the same thing, and hearing him say it out loud in a room full of strangers is a thing I will not describe to you.

Halbrook was removed from the firm by the executive committee in August and disbarred by the state bar in September.

I learned that from the letter they mailed to my house, because I had asked to be notified in writing.

Brielletta was charged with theft and records tampering, and she surrendered her records certification before her first court date.

Slate’s investigator license was revoked in Ohio in October, and the defense in Kessler was sanctioned for receiving privileged materials, which struck two of their central defenses and put my case back where it belonged.

The settlement came in November, and it was not a fraction of anything.

Delia Reeves called me at home on a Sunday, and I stood in my kitchen with the phone against my ear and listened to a woman I had apologized to in a parking lot tell me what the money would do for her grandchildren.

Then she said, “I don’t blame you, Neravine,” and I have thought about that sentence more than any other sentence in this whole business.

Quade pleaded to a lesser count in December, unauthorized access to a computer system, and he cooperated fully, and he was sentenced to probation and restitution.

Our divorce was final in March.

I kept the house and I kept the dog and I kept my name, and he kept the truck and the debts he had been trying to pay off with my client’s evidence.

The disciplinary office cleared my record in writing in February, in a two-page letter that said, in effect, that I had been used and that I had not been negligent.

Two people I had worked with for years have not spoken to me since the hearing, and I have stopped expecting them to.

I want to be honest about that part, because it is the part nobody puts in the ending.

Being right cost me a marriage and a mentor and two friendships, and I would do it again on the same Tuesday in the same room.

On a Friday in April I went back into that evidence room alone to sign the last Kessler exhibit.

The cabinets were the same and the light was the same and the cart was pushed against the far wall where it had always been.

I did not feel anything standing there, and it took me a minute to understand that the absence of fear was the feeling.

I signed my name on the last line, dated it, and closed the file.

Then I turned off the light and walked out and left the door unlocked behind me, because nothing in that room belonged to me anymore except the work, and the work was finished.