The Bottle Between Us
I stood with the champagne bottle lifted toward my husband, looking at his raised hands as though they belonged to someone I had never met.

Sophia had just gasped.

Behind Daniel, the birthday decorations I had arranged still hung above the table.

Nothing had fallen, nothing had broken, and I still had a chance to put the bottle down.
A moment earlier, I had been carrying a cake.

That was the part I kept returning to afterward, because I could remember being happy right up to the doorway.

I had turned thirty-eight that day, and I had worn the burgundy dress Daniel always said suited me.

I had picked up our cake myself because I wanted to walk into the private dining room holding it and make him smile.

He knew we were celebrating, but he did not know I had finished my errands early.

I had imagined him teasing me for taking charge of my own birthday again.

Instead, I found his mouth pressed to another woman’s.

It was not a kiss I could mistake for a greeting.

I saw the way they held each other, the closeness that continued for a moment before they noticed me standing there.

My smile disappeared before I understood that I had stopped walking.

The cake board pressed into my fingers.

I remember looking down at the words HAPPY BIRTHDAY because they were suddenly easier to look at than my husband.

When Daniel pulled away from Sophia, I searched his face for something that would change what I had seen.

I wanted him to look startled for a reason that did not involve betraying me.

But he looked from me to the cake, and I felt my eyes filling.

I set it on the table carefully.

That small act took an absurd amount of concentration.

I had to find an empty space, lower the board, and make sure the edge was supported while everything inside me seemed to be moving too fast.

“Explain this.”

My voice sounded thin rather than loud.

Daniel took a step toward me.

“Victoria, wait.”

I had waited through distracted dinners and evenings when he answered questions without looking up.

I had waited because he had told me we were going through a difficult stretch, and I had believed a difficult stretch was something we could cross together.

“This isn’t what it looks like,” he said.

Then Sophia moved beside him.

“Baby, just tell her.”

I heard that word more clearly than anything else in the room.

She had said it easily, as if she had forgotten for an instant that I was there.

My hand caught the stem of a champagne glass as I turned toward him, knocking it onto its side on the table.

It struck the surface with a hard little sound and stayed there.

“You promised you would tell me.”

I could barely get the words past the tightness in my throat.

I meant the conversation we had had when I first admitted that I felt shut out.

He had promised to tell me if something was wrong instead of leaving me to guess.

We had not been talking about another woman then, or at least I had not.

I saw the champagne bottle beside the fallen glass and reached for it.

I lifted it toward him before I had given myself a reason to do it.

Daniel backed away with both hands raised, and Sophia gasped.

Now I was standing there with the weight of it in my hand, frightened by how quickly my hurt had become something another person could fear.

What he had done was already real.

What I did next was still mine to decide.