Chapter 1 – The Scarf on the Carpet
I stood with my arm still pointing toward the front door after I screamed, waiting for my husband to leave the home I had been so happy to come back to.
The present lay open on the carpet between us.
One end of the scarf had slipped out of the tissue paper, and I could see the uneven stitches I had meant to fix before wrapping it.
Matthew looked down at it, then back at me.
“Sarah, let me explain.”
I shook my head because I could not bear another sentence beginning with my name in that familiar voice.
Only a few minutes earlier, I had been standing outside with the beautifully wrapped box tucked against my coat, trying to get my key into the lock without crushing the ribbon.
I had come home early on Christmas Eve because I wanted a little extra time with him before dinner.
There had been nothing complicated about what I wanted.
I wanted him to open the box, run his fingers over the scarf, and understand why I had kept a knitting bag hidden behind my winter boots for weeks.
He had mentioned needing a warmer scarf one morning in November, almost as an afterthought.
I had remembered.
Inside the house, I noticed the other scarf first.
It was draped over our sofa, soft and pale and unfamiliar, with one fringed end hanging over the cushion where I usually sat.
For a moment, I tried to fit it into an ordinary explanation.
Then I looked toward the Christmas tree.
Matthew was kissing Emily beside it, his face turned toward hers, their bodies close enough that I could not mistake what I was seeing.
I recognized her from the office gathering he had brought me to earlier that year.
He had introduced her as a coworker.
I remembered shaking her hand.
The sound that came out of me made them pull apart.
I was crying before I understood that I had started, and when Matthew stepped toward me, I screamed in disbelief.
“What are you doing?”
Emily stepped away from him with her mouth open, staring at me.
“Sarah, it was a mistake,” Matthew said.
He reached toward the box as though taking something out of my hands might help.
I threw the present onto the carpet before he could touch it.
The lid came loose when it landed, and the scarf I had knitted for him spilled into view.
I had imagined that moment so many times while making it, but never with Emily standing beside our Christmas tree.
I pointed toward the door.
“GET OUT!”
Now, with those words still hurting my throat, I watched Emily move toward the sofa to collect her scarf.
She fumbled with it before putting it around her neck.
I stepped aside so she could reach the door without coming close to me.
I heard her say she was sorry, but I could not answer her.
After she left, Matthew remained near the tree.
“We need to talk about this.”
I wiped my face with the heel of my hand.
“You need to leave.”
He picked up his keys from the entry table, moving slowly enough that I had to tell him again.
I did not ask where he would go.
When the door finally closed behind him, I locked it and kept my hand on the deadbolt until I heard his car start.
Then I sat on the bottom stair because my knees would not hold me anymore.
The tree lights were still on, and the open box was still where I had thrown it.
My phone vibrated in my coat pocket.
Matthew had written that the kiss had meant nothing and that he loved me.
I read his message twice, looking for something he had not included.
He still had not told me why Emily had been in our home.






