Caleb met his eyes. “I’ve said very little.”
Brett stopped for the first time since entering the diner. He seemed unsure which person in the room was creating the bigger problem.
Then Maya spoke behind him. “You still don’t know where it is.”
Brett turned back toward her. The room went still. Maya did not take the words back.
Brett walked toward the counter again, slower this time. “So, we agree there is something to find.”
Maya held his gaze. “We agree you came here looking for it.”
That answer did not satisfy him, but it confirmed something more important: Brett was no longer trying to convince the room that Maya might know something; he was trying to make her tell him how much she knew.
Brett stopped several feet from the counter and looked at Maya with a new level of attention.
“You just admitted you know there’s something here.”
“I admitted that you came looking for something.”
“That isn’t what you said.”
“It’s exactly what I said.”
“You said I don’t know where it is.”
Maya kept her expression neutral. “And you don’t.”
Brett turned toward Ruth. “I want the area behind the counter cleared.”
Ruth did not move. “For what?”
“So I can check it.”
“Check it for what?”
Brett’s voice tightened. “Department property.”
“You still haven’t described it.”
“I don’t have to discuss sensitive material in front of civilians.”
Ruth looked around the diner. “Then you shouldn’t have walked in here and announced that everyone might be a suspect.”
Daniel shifted on his stool. “She has a point.”
Brett turned toward him. “Stay out of it.”
“You’ve spent the last fifteen minutes putting me into it.”
“I asked you questions.”
“You told me leaving would put my name in a police report.”
“Because it could.”
Daniel nodded slowly. “Then don’t tell me I’m not involved.”
Brett looked at him for a moment before returning his attention to Ruth. “I’m asking for cooperation.”
“And I’m telling you no,” Ruth said. “You don’t open my drawers. You don’t go through my register. You don’t search my kitchen.”
“I haven’t said I’m searching anything.”
“Then there’s no reason for you to go behind my counter.”
Brett stepped toward the opening. Ruth moved into his path again. He stopped.
“Think carefully about what you’re doing.”
“I am. You could turn this place into part of an evidence investigation. You could also leave.”
Brett gave her a controlled smile. “You think the health department enjoys being called into places connected to police evidence?”
Ruth’s face hardened. “Are you threatening my business?”
“I’m telling you, investigations have consequences.”
Maya spoke from behind her. “Put that in writing.”
Brett looked at her.
“You want everything documented?” Maya asked. “Write down exactly what you just told her.”
His smile disappeared. “You’re very interested in reports tonight.”
“I’m interested in what people claim after the fact.”
That answer caught Caleb’s attention. He stayed seated, but watched Maya more closely.
Brett stepped away from Ruth and looked toward Eli. “Maybe we should start with the people who actually want to help.”
Eli frowned. “I never said that.”
“You know this town. You know Ruth. You know Maya. If somebody brought something into the diner, you might have seen it.”
“I already told you what I saw.”
“You told me you didn’t see anyone suspicious.”
“That’s right.”
“What about deliveries?”
Eli shook his head. “Wasn’t watching for them.”
“Someone using the restroom?”
“I don’t keep track of people going to the restroom.”
“Anyone near the register when Maya stepped away?”
Eli paused. “I don’t remember.”
Brett nodded. “So, something could have been left here without you noticing.”
Eli looked irritated. “Anything could happen if you ask the question that way.”
“I’m trying to establish possibilities.”
“No,” Eli said. “You’re trying to make every answer useful to you.”
Brett’s jaw tightened. He turned to Daniel. “What about you?”
Daniel leaned back. “What about me?”
“Did Maya leave the counter while you were here?”
“Yes.”
“Where did she go?”
“I don’t know. Kitchen, maybe.”
“How long?”
“I didn’t time her.”
“Did anyone approach the counter while she was gone?”
Daniel looked across the room as he tried to remember. “Not that I noticed.”
“‘Not that you noticed,'” Brett repeated.
Daniel exhaled. “You’re doing it again.”
“Doing what?”
“Turning normal uncertainty into suspicion.”
Brett took a step closer. “You’re an insurance adjuster. You know how investigations work. Details matter.”
“They do. So does context.”
“Then give me context.”
Daniel looked at Maya, then Ruth. “I came in for dinner. She took my order. I ate. You came in. Everything unusual started after that.”
Brett stared at him; Daniel did not look away.
Caleb spoke from the rear booth. “You’ve asked everyone except the person you claim brought the property here.”
Brett turned toward him. “I’ve asked her plenty.”
“No. You’ve accused her plenty.”
Brett walked toward Caleb. “You seem very interested in how I do my job.”
Caleb remained seated. “I’m interested in whether you’re doing it.”
Brett stopped beside the booth. “You want to test that?”
“No.”
“Then keep your opinions to yourself.”
Caleb looked at the badge still resting on the counter. “You put your authority in the middle of the room. People are going to have opinions about how you use it.”
Brett’s eyes narrowed.
Maya spoke before he could answer. “If you really want the property, call your supervisor.”
Brett turned. “Why?”
“Because you’ve already admitted it’s department property. If it matters enough to threaten everyone here, it matters enough to document properly.”
“I don’t need you to explain my job.”
“No, but you do need to explain why you’re doing this alone.”
Brett walked back toward her. “Maybe I’m giving you a chance.”
“To do what? Hand it over before your name ends up attached to something you can’t undo?”
Maya folded her arms. “You still haven’t identified what I’m supposed to hand over.”
“You know.”
“Then say it.”