Brett continued, “Because those are different matters. If this is administrative questioning related to my conduct as an officer, I want whatever representation is available under department policy. If you’re treating me as a potential criminal suspect, I’m not answering questions that could expose me without counsel.”
One of the younger officers glanced toward Price. She closed her notebook.
“Then don’t answer yet.”
Brett seemed caught off guard; Price continued: “I don’t need to decide your interview status in the middle of this diner just because you want an immediate answer.”
“I’m protecting my rights.”
“You should.”
“And department policy.”
“You should protect that, too.”
Brett studied her. Price opened the notebook again.
“Until I know exactly what happened here, I’m not going to force you into a statement and create another issue somebody has to untangle later.”
Brett folded his arms. Price looked toward Maya. “I’ll speak with Miss Williams separately.”
Brett immediately said, “She’s the person connected to the missing property.”
Price turned her head. “I heard you.”
“She has knowledge of it.”
“That may matter.”
“She also resisted detention.”
Price’s voice remained even. “Officer Kellen, if you keep answering questions I haven’t asked you, I’m going to have you wait outside with another officer.”
Brett stared at her. Price added, “That is not discipline. I’m separating witnesses and involved parties.”
“I’m not a witness.”
“I haven’t decided what you are yet.”
Brett stopped talking. Price approached Daniel first.
“I need your full name.”
“Daniel Ruiz.”
“You live in Briarwood?”
“No. I’m passing through.”
“Did you know Officer Kellen before tonight?”
“No.”
“Did you know Miss Williams?”
“No.”
“Mr. Ross?”
“No.”
“Mrs. Henderson?”
“No.”
“Mr. Barnes?”
“No.”
Price wrote that down. “What did you personally see when Officer Kellen entered?”
Daniel looked toward Brett; Price noticed. “Look at me, Mr. Ruiz. Don’t worry about whether he agrees.”
Daniel turned back. “He put his badge on the counter and said department property was inside the diner. Then he said anyone who left would have their name put on a suspect list in his report.”
Brett spoke from across the room. “That is not the exact wording.”
Price did not look at him. “Officer Kellen.” He stopped.
Daniel continued. “I asked if we were being detained. He said he never said that.”
“Did he physically block the door?”
“No.”
“Did he order you to remain seated?”
“No.”
“Why did you stay?”
“Because he made it sound like leaving would make me a suspect.”
Price wrote that down without comment.
Brett said, “That’s his interpretation.”
Price finally looked at him. “Yes, which is why I’m writing down the words he remembers and the reason he says he stayed. Later, we can separate fact from interpretation.”
Brett said nothing.
Price moved to Eli. “You know Officer Kellen?”
“Casually. Long time.”
“How long?”
“Years. Town’s not that big.”
“You friends?”
“No.”
“Enemies?”
“No.”
“What did you see between him and Maya Williams?”
Eli glanced at Brett. “He grabbed her.”
“Where?”
“First her apron and arm. Later, he held her up around here.” Eli touched his own upper shoulder and neck area; Price did not copy the gesture.
“What did Miss Williams say?”
“She told him to let go.”
“Once?”
“More than once.”
“What did Officer Kellen say?”
“He said she was resisting.”
“Was she?”
Eli hesitated. “I don’t know what police call resisting.”
Price nodded. “Then don’t tell me whether she was resisting. Tell me what her body was doing.”
“She was trying to get his arm off her.”
“Good. That I can use.”
Brett shifted his weight; Price noticed, but continued writing. She moved to Ruth next.
“You own the diner?”
“Thirty-two years.”
“Did you give anyone permission to search your business tonight?”
“No.”
“Did Officer Kellen ask for permission?”
“He asked to go behind my counter. I refused.”
“Did he present a warrant?”
“No.”
“Did he claim he had one?”
“No.”
Price wrote again.
Brett spoke. “I never conducted a search.”
Price looked at him. “That may be important.”
“It is important.”
“Then let me preserve that point accurately, instead of arguing about it.”
Brett’s mouth tightened. Price turned toward Caleb.
“Mr. Ross, you’re next. I want to know exactly when you stood up, exactly when you moved toward Officer Kellen, and exactly why.”
Caleb nodded. Before he spoke, Maya looked across the diner at him; Price caught the look. Then she looked back at Brett for the first time since arriving.
She had not asked anyone in the room to trust a badge, a waitress, an old soldier, or a frightened witness: she had asked them only to describe what they could prove they had seen. Brett could refuse to give Price his version for now; he could not stop her from collecting everyone else’s.
Price motioned Maya toward a table near the front window, far enough from Brett that he could not easily interrupt. Maya sat down. Price remained standing for a moment, then pulled out the chair across from her.
“I’m going to ask simple questions first.”
“All right.”
“Did you know Officer Kellen before tonight?”
“Yes.”
“How?”
Maya looked toward Brett briefly; Price noticed. “Answer me. Not him.”
“I knew him through previous work.”
“What kind of work?”
“Records.”
Price waited; Maya did not add anything. “Police records?”
“Some of them.”
Brett shifted across the diner. Price looked toward him. “Stay where you are.”
“I’m staying.”
She turned back to Maya. “When Brett came through that door, did you know what he was looking for?”
Maya paused. “I knew what he believed he was looking for.”
Price stopped writing. “That is a careful answer.”
“It is an accurate one.”
“Do you possess department property?”
“I did not take anything from the Briarwood Police Department.”
Price looked up. “That wasn’t my question.”
Brett spoke from behind her. “Exactly.”
Price turned. “Officer Kellen.”
He raised both hands slightly and stepped back. Price returned her attention to Maya.
“Do you currently possess anything that Brett claims belongs to the department?”