The pump clicked off. She topped it to the next dime, the way her father always had, and hung the nozzle back on the pump and screwed the fuel cap on and closed the little door. She pulled the receipt. She folded it and put it in the pocket of her coat. She took the car key out of the same pocket, because she had locked the car when she got out, out of the same habit that made her lock the shop door when she went to the bathroom. She walked to the driver’s door.
Behind her, the police car’s door opened and shut.
She turned around. She did it slowly, with the key in her right hand where he could see it, and her left hand open at her side.
He was coming across the lot toward her. He was bigger out of the car than in it, not tall so much as wide, a man in his fifties with a heavy neck and a gray brush mustache and a gut that pushed the front of his duty vest out over his belt. His hair was cut very short and had gone almost entirely white. Three stripes on each sleeve. The name tag over his pocket said KOPECKY. He walked like his knees hurt him. He did not walk toward her. That was the first strange thing. He walked toward the car, and when he got to it he did not come around to her side but stopped at the rear bumper, on the passenger side, and stood there looking at it, at the trunk lid and the taillights and the chrome of the bumper, the way the old men at gas stations looked at it. Then he walked slowly up the passenger side, trailing his eyes along the body, and when he got to the rear passenger door he stopped again.
He looked at the dent.
He looked at it for a long time. Long enough that the young man at the pickup truck across the island had stopped pretending to look at his own pump and was openly watching. Then the sergeant bent, with a little grunt, one hand on his knee, and put two fingers of his other hand into the dent, the way you would put your fingers into a footprint in wet cement to see how deep it went.
“Excuse me,” Selma said. “Can I help you, Officer?”
He straightened up. He came around the front of the car, past the squared-off grille and the star, and stopped six or seven feet from her, with the car’s long hood between them and the pump island at his back. Up close his face was red across the cheeks and nose in the way of a man who spent a lot of time outdoors or drank, or both, and his eyes were a very pale gray-blue, and they did not look at her. They looked past her, at the driver’s window, at the interior, at the dash.
“This your car?” he said.
“Yes.”
“This is your car.”
“Yes, sir. It’s my car.”
And he laughed.
It was not a big laugh. It was short, a single breath let out through the nose and the corner of the mouth, the kind of laugh a man gives when someone tells him the check is in the mail. It was the laugh of someone who had been told a story he had heard before. He shook his head a little, and for the first time he looked directly at her, and she watched him take her in, all of her, the navy blue coat and the plain gray scarf pinned under her chin and the work boots she had not changed out of and her face, which was forty-one years old and did not wear makeup on weekdays, and she watched him arrive at a conclusion.
“Okay,” he said. “Sure it is.”
“I’m sorry?”
“Ma’am.” He said it the way you would say it to a child who had been caught with a hand in a cookie jar and was explaining that the cookies had fallen in. “Come on. You’re telling me this is yours. This car. Your car.” His eyes went, very briefly, to her scarf and back. “Not your husband’s. Not your uncle’s. Not some guy’s who sold it to your cousin for cash out of a lot in East St. Louis. Yours.”
“Yes.”
He laughed again, shorter. “A lady like you.”
She said nothing. Across the island the young man with the pickup had finished fueling and hung up his nozzle and was standing by his truck with his hands in the pocket of his sweatshirt. The QuikTrip employee under the overhang had lowered her phone.






