Blake Nolan threw my brother’s backpack so hard that the sound of it hitting concrete cut through the noise of the football assembly.
“You knew exactly whose backpack that was!” I shouted.
The olive-green bag struck the ground between us, bounced once, and landed with its faded Northbridge athletics patch facing the sky. A line of stitching beneath the patch split open. For an instant, all I could see was a narrow sliver of transparent plastic. Then I looked up and saw Blake’s face.
He had been smiling when he grabbed my shirt. He wasn’t smiling anymore.
“Leave it,” he said.
He held one hand out, halfway between ordering me and asking me. Behind me, aluminum bleachers rattled as students leaned forward to watch. The bright November light made the metal look almost white, but there was nowhere for either of us to hide. Blake was six-foot-two, captain of the football team, and strong enough that a casual shove from him could knock me over. I was sixteen, barely five-foot-eight, and I had spent most of my life trying to keep out of everybody’s way.
I looked down at the strip of plastic beneath the torn patch. I had carried that backpack through school all day without knowing it was there.
“Why?” I asked.
“It’s trash.”
“Then why are you so worried about it?”
His gaze skipped past my shoulder. I turned just enough to see Mason Reed standing on the lowest bleacher stair, holding his phone upright. Mason and I had known each other since freshman year. He had a habit of filming anything that might turn into a story worth telling at lunch, and until that moment I had wished he would put his phone away.
“I said I don’t care,” Blake snapped.
I crouched to pick up the bag. Blake took a step toward me and reached for my shoulder.
“DON’T TOUCH HIM!” Mason called.
Heads turned. Even students who had been shouting over the assembly went quiet. Mason came down from the stair, phone still raised between us.
“I’m live,” he said. “Three hundred people are watching.”
I didn’t know whether the number was true. I only knew that Blake stopped.
I lifted the bag by its remaining strap. My brother had repaired that strap twice with thick black thread. Now the seam under the patch hung open, and a little clear sleeve protruded from a pocket I hadn’t known existed. I eased it out. Inside was a microSD card, the kind smaller than a fingernail, with a folded piece of paper attached.
The handwriting was Aaron’s. Even after fourteen months, I recognized the hard slant of his capitals. The note said: GIVE DIRECTLY TO KELLER.
My stomach went cold. Blake leaned close enough to read it. All the color seemed to leave his face.
“Ethan,” he whispered. “Don’t.”
Mason moved between us. “Back up, Blake.”
For a moment, I could hear nothing but the faint hiss of Mason’s phone microphone and someone walking on the bleacher stairs above us. Blake stared at the sleeve as though it had opened a door he’d spent a year holding shut.
Fourteen months earlier, before anyone at Northbridge High knew my family as the family with the thief, I would have assumed Blake was scared of getting caught bullying me. That afternoon I knew better. His fear began the instant he saw what was under the patch, before he noticed the phone. He recognized something about my brother’s bag that I didn’t.
Coach Richard Nolan came along the walkway from the administration building. His burgundy polo matched the school colors, and the whistle at his neck swung with every fast step. He was Blake’s father and the person adults on this campus seemed least willing to contradict.
“What is going on here?” he demanded.
“Dad—” Blake started.
But Coach had seen the sleeve in my hand. He stopped. His expression changed so quickly that, later, I would replay it in my mind as often as the bag hitting the ground.
“Ethan, give that to me.”
“No.”
“It may contain school property.”
“It came from my brother’s backpack.”
Coach Nolan pointed toward the worn patch. “The athletics patch belongs to Northbridge.”
I looked down at the crooked thread holding it to Aaron’s canvas. “So now you’re claiming my brother’s bag because of a patch?”
“Cooperate, Ethan.”
I slipped the entire sleeve into my shirt pocket. The plastic scratched lightly against my chest through my T-shirt. I was afraid Coach would simply reach in and take it, and even more afraid that nobody would stop him.
“Aaron said it goes to Dr. Keller,” I told him.
Coach glanced toward Blake. Blake wouldn’t meet his eyes.
“I’m Dr. Keller,” said a woman behind him.
She had approached from the administration walkway with Principal Warren, who looked as if he’d been trying to catch up without appearing to hurry. Dr. Naomi Keller wore a navy suit and carried a tablet. She wasn’t tall or especially loud. Still, when she spoke, even Coach turned.
She introduced herself as an investigator working on the state education department’s review of Northbridge’s stadium renovation grant. “I understand you have something for me.”
I pulled out the sleeve. For one absurd second I thought about how much smaller the card was than the accusation it might answer. Then I gave it to her.
Coach Nolan immediately said the contents might have been obtained illegally. Principal Warren called the whole thing a misunderstanding involving a former student. Neither of them asked whether Aaron was all right.
Dr. Keller examined the handwriting without unfolding the paper farther than she needed to. “Then we’ll preserve it and determine what it is,” she said.
“Before you examine that,” Coach began, “I need to explain something.”
“Explain what, Coach?”
He looked at his son again. This time Blake stared at the concrete.
Dr. Keller turned to the principal. “I need a secure computer and a private room.”
“Is that really necessary?” Warren asked.






