Before lunch, a girl from Maya’s geometry class caught her near the water fountain. The girl grinned, raised both fists like a boxer, and said people were calling Maya the “captain killer.” A second student laughed from behind her.

“I didn’t kill anybody,” Maya said. “I didn’t even hit him.”

“It’s a joke,” the girl answered. “Everybody knows what I mean.”

“But Chloe was on the floor while everybody watched. It’s a weird thing to make into a joke.”

The girl’s smile faded. “I didn’t mean Chloe.”

“That’s the problem. Nobody seems to.”

Maya walked on before the conversation could turn into an argument about whether she was allowed to feel offended. She didn’t want to become a school-wide referee for other people’s jokes. Yet the encounter made something clear: the approving rumors and accusing rumors were built from the same missing pieces. In both, Chloe was a background shape and Maya’s hand was the entire plot. A story that praised Maya for being violent could still leave Chloe alone.

In the restroom, Maya checked whether she looked as exhausted as she felt. Her ponytail had come loose and a piece of hair stuck to her cheek. She washed her hands, then took a slow inventory of what she’d heard that morning. Nobody had claimed to be an eyewitness to the tray’s fall in front of her. The loudest speakers had played the same short clip repeatedly. The fact that a dozen people repeated an account did not turn them into twelve independent witnesses.

She considered typing a school-wide message correcting the tale. Her thumb hovered over the compose button. She could imagine the screenshot being taken out of context, a sentence about Trent’s fist becoming a claim that she wanted to hurt him. She put the phone away. A correction could wait until she had asked Chloe whether publicity would help her at all. Maya might have been the student standing in front, but the experience had started with Chloe, not with her.

When Maya reached the cafeteria door, she looked across the room for someone who wanted a seat instead of another audience.

At lunch, the central tables seemed louder than ever. A second adult stood near the east aisle, and a caution sign had been removed from the cleaned floor. Maya walked in with a sandwich, scanning for Chloe before she remembered that she was supposed to ask where Chloe wanted to eat, not decide for her. She found her near a window along the south wall, facing an untouched carton of milk.

“Can I sit?” Maya asked.

Chloe looked startled that anyone would ask. “Yeah.”

Her navy jacket was gone; she wore a gray cardigan, and a small bandage showed below one knee. Her notebook lay closed beside her tray. Yesterday’s corner damage remained, even though she had flattened the pages beneath books overnight.

“I thought you might avoid the cafeteria,” Maya said.

“I tried eating in the library last week,” Chloe answered. “Ms. Donnelly said food wasn’t allowed. I spent the period pretending to browse dictionaries.” She paused. “I wanted to see if I could be here today.”

Maya set down her sandwich. “You don’t have to prove anything to anybody.”

“Maybe I’m proving it to myself.”

They ate for a moment without speaking. In the center of the room, Trent was at a different table with two teammates. He didn’t approach them. Once, as he walked toward the trash cans, his face turned their way, but the supervising adult was close by and he kept moving. Chloe stared at her sandwich until he passed.

“Did anyone ask you what happened?” Maya said.

“A lot of people asked whether you hurt him. Almost nobody asked if I was okay.”

“That was what I was afraid of.”

Chloe picked at a corner of the notebook. “When they say you humiliated him, they make it sound like the day started when he slipped. I keep thinking about my jacket lying wet in the nurse’s office. That part doesn’t get a replay.”

Maya wanted to offer something large and comforting. She settled for asking what would make lunch easier. Chloe said she wanted to keep coming to the cafeteria and didn’t want a crowd watching her every time she entered. She wasn’t certain whether she wanted someone walking with her or whether that would make her more noticeable. Maya told her they could decide one day at a time.

Later, after chemistry, a teacher passed out a safety reminder about using phones respectfully during school incidents. It didn’t mention the cafeteria. Several students exchanged knowing smiles. Maya wondered whether school-wide reminders changed anybody’s mind or merely gave everybody another subject to pretend wasn’t specific.

She found Avery Kim by the art-room bulletin board, where a student exhibition of charcoal drawings had been mounted. Avery was examining a sketch of a train station. Her maroon hoodie looked too warm for the building; she had pushed the sleeves over her hands.

“Can I ask you something about Monday?” Maya said.

Avery’s shoulders tightened. “People have been asking me all day.”

“I saw you with your phone. You were near the southwest side of the circle.”

“A lot of people were filming.”

“I know. Did yours start before I touched Trent?”

Avery glanced down the hall. “Yes.”

Maya waited. It took effort not to move closer or press her with more questions.

“I heard the tray fall,” Avery continued. “I didn’t start filming until after that. I caught the notebook going down the aisle. And the other stuff.”

“Do you still have the original?”

“Yes.”

“Please don’t delete it. And don’t post it for everybody. Ms. Price needs to see it privately.”

Avery pushed up her glasses. “Do you know what happens if people find out I gave them a video?”

“I don’t know. I can guess.”

“Trent’s friends sit behind me in biology. My sister’s on the student athletic committee. It’s not as simple as pushing send.”